Free Shipping on Orders over $100
15% Off Through 4/16/24
Skip to content
Home
About Us
About Us
Cheese
Cheese Selections
Cheese Club
Cheese Trays
Food
Breads & Scones
Charcuterie
Condiments & Aioli
Dips & Seasonings
Jams, Honey & Confits
Locally Roasted Coffee
Pastas & Sauces
Sweets & Nuts
All
Olive Mill
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Accessories
Cheese Accessories
Beer Accessories
Cocktail Accessories
Home Accessories
Kitchen Accessories
Olive Oil Accessories
Wine Accessories
Apparel
Gifts
Cheese Club Gift
Gift Certificates
12 Cheeses of Christmas
All Gift Ideas
Wine Shop
Red Wine
White Wine
Rose Wine
Sweet Wine
Sparkling Wine
90+ Wines
Spirits (Pick Up Only)
Home
About Us
About Us
Cheese
Cheese Selections
Cheese Club
Cheese Trays
Food
Breads & Scones
Charcuterie
Condiments & Aioli
Dips & Seasonings
Jams, Honey & Confits
Locally Roasted Coffee
Pastas & Sauces
Sweets & Nuts
All
Olive Mill
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Accessories
Cheese Accessories
Beer Accessories
Cocktail Accessories
Home Accessories
Kitchen Accessories
Olive Oil Accessories
Wine Accessories
Apparel
Gifts
Cheese Club Gift
Gift Certificates
12 Cheeses of Christmas
All Gift Ideas
Wine Shop
Red Wine
White Wine
Rose Wine
Sweet Wine
Sparkling Wine
90+ Wines
Spirits (Pick Up Only)
Clear
Search
0
Cart
Recently Viewed
Add
Home
About Us
About Us
Cheese
Cheese Selections
Cheese Club
Cheese Trays
Food
Breads & Scones
Charcuterie
Condiments & Aioli
Dips & Seasonings
Jams, Honey & Confits
Locally Roasted Coffee
Pastas & Sauces
Sweets & Nuts
All
Olive Mill
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Accessories
Cheese Accessories
Beer Accessories
Cocktail Accessories
Home Accessories
Kitchen Accessories
Olive Oil Accessories
Wine Accessories
Apparel
Gifts
Cheese Club Gift
Gift Certificates
12 Cheeses of Christmas
All Gift Ideas
Wine Shop
Red Wine
White Wine
Rose Wine
Sweet Wine
Sparkling Wine
90+ Wines
Spirits (Pick Up Only)
Home
About Us
About Us
About Us
Cheese
Cheese
Cheese Selections
Cheese Club
Cheese Trays
Food
Food
Breads & Scones
Charcuterie
Condiments & Aioli
Dips & Seasonings
Jams, Honey & Confits
Locally Roasted Coffee
Pastas & Sauces
Sweets & Nuts
All
Olive Mill
Olive Mill
Olive Oil
Balsamic Vinegar
Accessories
Accessories
Cheese Accessories
Beer Accessories
Cocktail Accessories
Home Accessories
Kitchen Accessories
Olive Oil Accessories
Wine Accessories
Apparel
Gifts
Gifts
Cheese Club Gift
Gift Certificates
12 Cheeses of Christmas
All Gift Ideas
Wine Shop
Wine Shop
Red Wine
White Wine
Rose Wine
Sweet Wine
Sparkling Wine
90+ Wines
Spirits (Pick Up Only)
Register / Login
Search
Search
Search
Clear
Collection
Cheese
Filter
Sort
Clear
Quick shop
14 year White Cheddar
$ 14.50
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
14 year White Cheddar
From $ 14.50
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
5 year Yellow Cheddar
$ 8.63
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
5 year Yellow Cheddar
From $ 8.63
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Milton's Prairie Breeze
$ 11.00
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
0.5 lbs
1.0 lbs
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Milton's Prairie Breeze
From $ 11.00
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Black Truffle 8oz
$ 12.50
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Black Truffle 8oz
$ 12.50
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Garlic Peppercorn 8oz
$ 12.00
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Garlic Peppercorn 8oz
$ 12.00
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Hot Pepper Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.00
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Hot Pepper Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.00
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Hunter Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.50
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Hunter Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.50
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Sage & Herb 8oz
$ 12.00
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Sage & Herb 8oz
$ 12.00
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Smoked Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.50
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Default Title
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Plymouth Artisan Cheese Smoked Cheddar 8oz
$ 12.50
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Springside Flavored Cheddars 0.5 lb
$ 6.13
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Flavor
Beer Cheddar
Caraway Cheddar
Cheddar Blue
Garlic & Herb Garlic
Maple White Cheddar
Olive Cheddar
White Bacon Cheddar
Horseradish & Chive
Beer Cheddar
Caraway Cheddar
Cheddar Blue
Garlic & Herb Garlic
Maple White Cheddar
Olive Cheddar
White Bacon Cheddar
Horseradish & Chive
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Springside Flavored Cheddars 0.5 lb
$ 6.13
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Springside Flavored Cheddars 1 lb
$ 12.25
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Flavor
Beer Cheddar
Caraway Cheddar
Cheddar Blue
Garlic & Herb Garlic
Maple White Cheddar
Olive Cheddar
White Bacon Cheddar
Horseradish & Chive
Beer Cheddar
Caraway Cheddar
Cheddar Blue
Garlic & Herb Garlic
Maple White Cheddar
Olive Cheddar
White Bacon Cheddar
Horseradish & Chive
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Springside Flavored Cheddars 1 lb
$ 12.25
Unit price
/
per
Quick shop
Tipperary Irish Cheddar
$ 8.88
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
lbs
0.5 lb
1.0 lb
0.5 lb
1.0 lb
Quantity
Quantity selected exceeds current stock
Add to Cart
Tipperary Irish Cheddar
From $ 8.88
Unit price
/
per
You're viewing 1-12 of 23 products
Load More
Filter
Availability
In stock
12
Out of stock
13
Price
The highest price is $ 35.00
$
From
–
$
To
Milk
Cow
3
Brand
Balfour Farms
3
Bwlchwernen Fawr
1
Dairygold Co-op
1
Galena River Wine & Cheese
3
LaClare Family Creamery
2
Milton's Creamery
2
Plymouth Artisan Cheese
8
Springside Artisan Cheese
2
Wisconsin Grader's Reserve
1
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Availability